A federal judge has returned New York's enforcement case against prediction-market operator Kalshi to state court, rejecting the company's effort to keep the dispute in federal court. U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick signed the remand order on November 19, finding that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction. The decision sends the case back to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County, where state officials are seeking to apply New York gambling law to Kalshi's event contracts.

The ruling concerns jurisdiction, not the merits

New York filed the action on July 31, alleging that Kalshi was operating an unlicensed gambling platform in the state. Those allegations remain contested and were not decided by Broderick's order. The judge concluded that Kalshi could not create federal jurisdiction by raising a federal-law defense based on the Commodity Exchange Act. Because the court lacked jurisdiction, it also said it could not rule on Kalshi's request for a protective order against state enforcement.

Related reporting: Fourth Circuit Lets Maryland Enforce Wagering Rules on Kalshi

The practical result is a change of forum, not a final judgment that New York has won. The remand does not cancel Kalshi's federal designation as a contract market, decide whether particular contracts violate state law or independently direct the exchange to stop operating. Broderick also denied New York's request for attorneys' fees, finding that Kalshi had an objectively reasonable basis for attempting removal even though the effort failed.

Federal and state authority remain in conflict

Kalshi argues that federal commodities regulation preempts state gambling rules for contracts traded on a federally regulated designated contract market. New York maintains that its police powers still reach gambling activity offered to residents. That disagreement is part of a wider national dispute over whether sports and other event contracts are financial derivatives under exclusive federal supervision or wagers that states may restrict.

The legal landscape is unsettled. Reuters reported that three federal appeals courts have allowed states to regulate Kalshi, while a separate appeals court in New Jersey reached the opposite conclusion. The split increases the possibility that the issue will require further appellate review. It also means that a ruling in one jurisdiction does not automatically settle Kalshi's position in every state.

The CFTC's emergency request was also denied

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission separately asked another federal judge to stop New York from acting against Kalshi while the agency pursued its own preemption case. On November 20, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied that emergency request, according to Reuters, saying the CFTC had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits. That ruling did not finally resolve the agency's case, but it removed the immediate federal barrier the regulator had sought.

What comes next

New York's case can now proceed in state court, where Kalshi may continue to challenge the requested enforcement measures and argue that federal law displaces state restrictions. CoinDesk reported that a proposed temporary restraining order remained pending when the remand was issued. Until the state judge rules on that request or the parties obtain further appellate relief, descriptions of Kalshi as already shut down in New York would go beyond the record. The next decisions will matter not only for Kalshi but also for other prediction markets trying to offer nationwide event contracts under a single federal framework.

Sources

AI-generated editorial image; not a photograph of the reported event. Prepared with AI assistance and source verification.