A divided court left Maryland enforcement in place
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed a lower court's refusal to block Maryland from applying its sports-wagering laws to Kalshi's sports event contracts. The 2-1 decision in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin leaves the state's enforcement authority in place while the underlying litigation continues. Kalshi operates a Commodity Futures Trading Commission-regulated designated contract market and argues that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over contracts traded on its exchange. Maryland says the sports contracts amount to wagering offered without the state license required for operators serving residents. The dispute began after Maryland gaming authorities sent the company a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025 and Kalshi sought declaratory and injunctive relief later that month.
The majority agreed on the result, not the reasoning
Judge Roger Gregory assumed without deciding that Kalshi's sports contracts are swaps, but concluded that the company had not shown Congress clearly displaced Maryland's traditional authority over gambling. He also found no unavoidable conflict between federal regulation and state licensing or advertising rules. Judge Stephanie Thacker took a different path, concluding that the sports event contracts are not swaps and therefore do not fall within the CFTC's exclusive swap jurisdiction. Their separate opinions produced a judgment affirming the district court rather than a single majority rationale on the central statutory question.
Related reporting: CFTC Sues Arkansas and Louisiana in Prediction-Market Jurisdiction Fight
The dissent favored exclusive federal jurisdiction
Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented. She would treat the contracts as swaps traded on a federally regulated market and place them within the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Kalshi said the separate opinions show that courts have not developed a unified legal theory against prediction markets. The company has maintained that state-by-state gambling regulation is incompatible with the federal framework governing designated contract markets. The court's judgment rejected Kalshi's request for immediate protection from Maryland enforcement, but the differing opinions preserve substantial disagreement over how the Commodity Exchange Act applies.
Maryland emphasized licensing and consumer safeguards
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said the ruling permits the state to enforce protections covering customer data, deceptive advertising and marketing to people who are barred from wagering or considered at risk of gambling harm. The state's gaming authorities sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025 and argued that the platform must obtain a sports-wagering license to offer these contracts in Maryland. Gregory's opinion described the state's requirements as conditions on entities choosing to offer sports contracts to Maryland residents, rather than regulation of designated contract markets as such.
The nationwide legal picture remains unsettled
Federal appellate courts have split over whether state gambling laws can reach sports event contracts on federally regulated prediction markets. Reuters reported that two other appeals courts have ruled against Kalshi while another concluded New Jersey could not regulate the company; CoinDesk counted three of four appellate outcomes as favoring state oversight. Those decisions rest on different analyses of whether the contracts are swaps and whether federal law preempts state rules. The disagreement creates practical uncertainty for exchanges that operate nationally but face licensing demands, geofencing orders and consumer-protection rules imposed state by state. It also leaves regulators without a uniform answer about where federal market supervision ends and state gambling authority begins. The Fourth Circuit ruling concerns preliminary relief, not a final merits judgment, and its fractured reasoning does not establish one nationwide standard. Further appeals remain possible, but no higher-court review is guaranteed.
Sources
- KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892
- Statement from Attorney General Brown on Fourth Circuit Decision in Kalshi Case
- Kalshi loses bid to prevent Maryland from policing prediction market
- Another U.S. appellate court goes against Kalshi, building the industry's legal headwinds
AI-generated editorial image; not a photograph of the reported event. Prepared with AI assistance and source verification.
